Chevy Colorado & GMC Canyon banner

Which oil to use?

57K views 92 replies 33 participants last post by  littleblazer  
#1 ·
Manual states “Use SAE 5W-30 viscosity grade engine oil. Cold Temperature Operation: In an area of extreme cold, where the temperature falls below −29 °C (−20 °F), an SAE 0W-30 oil may be used. An oil of this viscosity grade will provide easier cold starting for the engine at extremely low temperatures.”

I live in Alberta Canada. Where in the winter it does regularly get below -29. But it does fluctuate above that too, so what would you guys recommend to use?

also, it states to use dextos oil? Which I’m kinda confused about. Will Mobil 1 synthetic 5w30 be fine?
 
#64 ·
GM gives you a powertrain warranty. They expect you to follow the OLM and bring it to the dealership for an oil change. Why would they not tell you to bring it in every 3k miles for an oil change to 1. protect the engine with very clean oil all the time, and 2. have you pay for more oil changes? If anything, the OLM is conservative. So general rule of thumb, is change it every 7k miles or less depending on what you're doing. The OLM is most likely trust worthy. I've seen videos of cars with 20k miles on the original oil, and granted you should never do that, but besides being dirty af and more than likely had some more wear, they were running fine. So going slightly over the "Perfect" oil change interval probably won't make much difference in the long run either. Idk. It's just not that serious imo.

Definitely run a full bottle of seafoam in the crank case though. Keeps the engine clean. That's my strange method ;) @SyN
 
#65 ·
You know something funny? My OLM based interval is between 5-7k miles too. Really coincidental how that works out... I'd imagine the new ones are also just as good. :rolleyes:
 
owns 2019 Chevrolet Colorado Z71
#67 · (Edited)
Jr is not your Shade Tree Mechanic - trying to convince You to run the Oil he uses.
He is a Certified Lubrication Specialist - with many years of experience.

Yes there are many still whom will think they will know more then he - but that's ok - opinions are like you know what!
Some might not agree with Jr’s thoughts & results - which does Not make his findings wrong.

Anyway- for those always infatuated with the lubrication of your expensive investment - give his videos a watch.

 
  • Like
Reactions: cb4017 and Mr Stig
#68 ·
Yes, I have been watching all his YouTube videos. He knows his stuff.

Also, for all of the doubters, check out Dave's auto repair videos. He has plenty of them showing the absolutely devastating effects of extended oil change interval inside the engine.

As others have pointed out, you do you, after all, it's your truck. You make the call.

Me, because I don't want to buy another truck and it has a turbo, my oil changes are between 3000 & 5000 miles maximum. It is fantastic that the very first thing after the oil filter is the tube that oils the turbo but turbos like clean oil.

Bottom line is, it costs about the same to change the oil as it does to test the oil. So I will change it.

I have also seen inside an engine that I bought new and ran it 100,000 miles and I changed the oil every 5k. I simply couldn't believe how much sludgy crap was inside the engine. I also used the name brand full synthetic oil from new. It didn't matter.

I changed the oil and filter at 100k and added a quart of diesel fuel to the fresh oil & let it idle for 15 minutes. Oil came out as black as coal. Did it a second time too. Oil still came out dirty but was much better than the first time. Then ran it for a day with cheap full synthetic in it and drained it again. It was pretty darn clean looking. We got over 230k on that car before we sold it.

So even using high quality full synthetic oil from new and changing it every 5k still left sludgy junk inside engine. CHANGE YOUR OIL ! LOL
 
#69 ·
I'm not here to debate Lake's qualifications or agenda, I've watched a few of his videos and my biggest issue with his content is that he repeats "science, not speculation" as his mantra but in the same video has actually made statements based purely on speculation and not facts/science. I'm skeptical of any self-proclaimed experts that make hypocritical or contradictory statements. I'm not discarding or disputing the facts that he presents that are backed up by data/science and transparency, however I'm also not going to blindly accept that everything he says is gospel unless he can prove it. Case in point, he made a blanket statement that mfr OCIs are too long and oil is past EOL if you follow their recommended intervals. No data to back it up, it was an off-the-cuff answer when he was asked this question. In the same video he spoke about how useful/important UOA is to track how your engine is wearing (and he even has his own UOA company). As someone that has done UOA and follows the OLM I can say that my science/data trumps his opinion. I would've much rather he tell people how they can test for themselves if their OCI is too long or not than to just make a blanket statement that is easy to disprove, something that is antithetical to what he claims to be about.

Skepticism in the science community is a good thing, this shouldn't be taken as me not liking him or throwing shade due to a difference of opinion but rather doing what folks should do and be skeptical/ask questions/test for yourself if someone makes a statement without backing it up with proof.
 
owns 2017 GMC Canyon Denali
#75 ·
Aaaaaand it's a waste of money. :D

 
#77 ·
how about 5w-40 in the summer and 5w-30 in the winter. Dexos approved of course. i like/use castrol full syn. 🛢🛢🛢
 
#78 ·
To what end? Both will flow the same when cold, the difference is that the 5w30 will have less viscosity once up to temperature and ambient temp doesn't play a huge role here as normal operating temp for oil is well above ambient.
 
owns 2017 GMC Canyon Denali
#84 ·
I just got my 2018 Colorado this month, but prior to that I had a 2000 Express 1500 and after 100K miles I switched to Royal Purple 5w-30 which is Dexos rated. I switched when the lifters started ticking and the tick went away and I drove it another 100K without any problems. Those Vortec V6s were great motors. I plan to do the same with this V6 Colorado.
 
#85 ·
Sounds like a good plan, but keep in mind that this thread is about 3rd gen trucks and you have a 2nd gen.
 
owns 2017 GMC Canyon Denali
  • Like
Reactions: low-tec
#89 ·
+1 on the Royal Purple 5w-30; I used it in my gen2 and it is currently in my gen3. On another thread here I saw it also was also the least volatile of DEXOS approved oils, which may also slightly abate the DI inflicted carbon buildup as well.

I dunno if it has any effect on the L3B, but the/a 'fix' for the problems plaguing the V8s is to change out the stock 0w-40 oil to a 5w-30 or 40.
 
#90 ·
+1 on the Royal Purple 5w-30; I used it in my gen2 and it is currently in my gen3. On another thread here I saw it also was also the least volatile of DEXOS approved oils, which may also slightly abate the DI inflicted carbon buildup as well.

I dunno if it has any effect on the L3B, but the/a 'fix' for the problems plaguing the V8s is to change out the stock 0w-40 oil to a 5w-30 or 40.
The V8s use a 0w20.
 
owns 2019 Chevrolet Colorado Z71