Both together to start. That way people don't have to pay a mount and balance fee to get them on their truck...they can just bolt them on and go.
Then if you don't get any bites after a while and you don't want to lower the price, then sell them separately.

 

I agree with your logic 100%. However, I was just looking for an excuse to spend even more money to put some Bigger Nitto Ridge Grapplers on there instead of using the stock tires first. 😁

 

I think it will all depend on how much you think you'd ask and how quickly you want them to sell. You'll likely net more money selling them separate because you'll have a wider audience vs selling together and needing to find a buyer that would be interested in both, otherwise you're going to have lowball offers from people that only want the wheels or tires and don't want to pay for what they don't want. That was kind of the situation I was in a couple years back, I wanted some 17" wheels to replace my factory 20" but I didn't want to spend $1,000+ on wheels and then have to spend another $1,000+ on tires. So, I bided my time and eventually someone popped up selling some ZR2 wheels with near-new (but not factory) Duratrac tires. I ended up getting a set of 5 ZR2 wheels and 5 basically brand-new 265/70R17 Duratrac tires for $1,000.

If the OEM tires are ones you wouldn't mind running then I'd mount them to the new wheels and sell the factory wheels. If you're not a fan of the factory tires and want something else then I'd sell both, but whether they are sold as a package deal or separate depends on what I mentioned above.

 

Thank you for the thorough response. I will take your advice. I do like the stock tires so I will use them and just sell the wheels at a fair price.